A GP in Dubai is assessing a 15-month-old girl with gastroenteritis. According to systematic review evidence, which combination of findings is most useful for detecting at least 5% dehydration?
Rationale
The JAMA rational clinical examination review (Steiner 2004) found that the three most useful individual signs for at least 5% dehydration are prolonged capillary refill time, abnormal skin turgor and an abnormal (deep, acidotic) respiratory pattern. No single sign is reliable on its own, so a combination of signs or a validated scale such as the Clinical Dehydration Scale should be used. Accurate pre-illness weight compared with current weight is the gold standard but is rarely available. NICE CG84 uses these and other features as red flags to separate clinical dehydration from shock. Parental history and dry mucosa are less specific because mouth-breathing and crying affect them.
Why the other options are wrong:
- A. Tears, dry lips and parental report are subjective and much less accurate.
- B. Thirst and fever are non-specific, and the fontanelle is closed in many toddlers.
- C. Hypotension and weak pulses are late signs of decompensated shock; they are too insensitive to detect 5% dehydration.
Where to revise: Study PDF: "Dehydration in Children: Assess, Rehydrate, Re-feed" (KnowMed), page 4: Estimating severity: percent of body weight; page 7: Who needs blood and stool tests